Please note that English muffin orders are shipped Monday-Wednesday and should be placed before 2:00pm EST for same or next day shipment. *WE SHIP NATIONWIDE!*

Vegetable English Muffin Pizza Recipe

To make this vegetable English muffin pizza recipe (using our Dam Good English Muffins) that we created in collaboration with Headwater Food Hub first grab a bag of your favorite sourdough Dam Good™ English Muffin variety (we used vegan "Original White," and "Whole Wheat")!

Caramelized Butternut Squash & Shallots English Muffin Pizza Recipe

What you'll need:
  • 2 Dam Good™ English Muffins, halved
  • 1 Package of organic Martin Farms Fresh Cut Squash (or cube your own)
  • Jones Family Farms Mozzarella; sliced
  • 4 T Jones Family Farms Kuyahoora Cream Cheese
  • 1 Shallot - sliced
  • 3 Oz of Whole In The Wall Spinach Parmesan Pesto
  • 1 T Brown Sugar
  • 2 T Butter
  • 2 Kale Leaves; shredded
  • Sage; fresh or dried
Steps for Vegetable English Muffin Pizza:
  1. Firstly, pre-heat the oven to 400 degrees (and defrost the Whole In The Wall Pesto).
  2. Meanwhile, CARAMELIZE!
  3. Then, add 2 T of butter to a pan on medium heat, add the pre-cubed butternut, diced shallots, and 1 T of brown sugar or maple syrup.
  4. Next. reduce the heat to low and cook, stirring often, for 20 minutes or until soft.
  6. Then, start with the pesto, then dollop cream cheese, followed by cartelized squash & shallots, finish with the mozzarella and kale.
  7. Then, bake at 400 for 10-15 minutes.
  8. Lastly, eat those Vegetable English Muffin pizzas!

Mushroom & Pesto English Muffin Pizza Recipe

What you’ll need:
  • 2 Dam Good™ English Muffins, halved
  • 2 Beets, peeled & cubed (we used Cylindra Beets)
  • 1 Head of garlic, roasted
  • 3 Oz Whole In The Wall Spinach Parmesan Pesto
  • 3 or 4 Baby Bella Mushrooms, sliced and caramelized
  • 1 T Butter
  • Jones Family Farms Mozzarella Cheese, sliced
  • 2 Kale leaves, shredded
  • This is so good topped with pickled jalapeños or other spicy stuff!
Steps for Vegetable English Muffin Pizza:
  1. Firstly, pre-heat the oven to 400 degrees
  2. Then, peel & dice the beets, then wrap in aluminum foil. Roast until soft - about 30 minutes.
  3. Next, slice the top off the garlic, and wrap in aluminum foil. Splash with olive oil and roast.
  4. Meanwhile, CARAMELIZE!
  5. Then, melt 1 T of butter in a pan. Add the mushrooms with a dash of salt; sauté until browned.
  6. Next, combine roasted beets & garlic with pesto in a blender or food processor. Add water to thin as needed starting with 1 t at a time
  8. Start with the pesto, then add mushrooms. Top with cheese, and kale. Bake at 400 for 10-15 minutes, and enjoy these homemade vegetable English muffin pizzas!
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Dam Good™ English Muffins (@damgoodenglishmuffins) on

For this sourdough English muffin pizza recipe, we made our vegetable English muffin pizza in the oven, however feel free to explore the other English muffin pizza cooking methods below:

  • English muffin pizzas in the toaster oven 
  • English muffin pizzas in air fryer for air fryer English muffin pizzas
  • Note: English Muffin Pizza Oven Temperatures and English muffin pizza cook time vary depending on the appliance used

Further, check out our other homemade sourdough English Muffin Pizza recipes:

Similarly, you can make any of these English muffin pizza recipes vegan by simply swapping the cheese for a plant-based cheese, and using a vegan meat alternative.

Featured Products:

Older Post
Newer Post
Close (esc)

Help support women & non-binary owned businesses this holiday season

Customize an English muffin gift box for everyone on your list!

*Please note that we are UNABLE to replace or refund any orders that are delayed, stolen, or lost in transit this holiday season unless they are covered by Route Package Protection.*

Build a gift box

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now